Tuesday, November 4, 2014

Soccer Racism in Mexico

In September 2014, Ronaldinho, the former Brazil and Barcelona star who won the FIFA player of the year two times, joined the Mexican local club Queretaro. Even before playing his first match along with his new teammates, Ronaldinho was subject of various racist attacks.



According to Abc News, Mexico has always had a long history of racism. Since the Mexican revolution, the country has always been deeply divided and one part of Mexico has always been in conflict with another: urban vs. rural, rich vs. poor, and dark-skinned vs. dark or light skinned individuals. While in Europe, soccer racism involves whites insulting blacks; soccer racism in Mexico mostly includes dark-skinned individuals verbally or physically insulting at other dark-skinned people. This issue can be very similar to the Hutu and Tutsi conflict that, even though sharing many similar features (including skin color), still shared many racial and ethnic conflicts between the twos.



One of the major attacks was from a former official of the Queretaro state government, Carlos Trevino. Trevino explicitly attacked Ronaldinho on Facebook even before playing his first game with the new team. On Facebook, Trevino wrote, “Seriously, I try to be tolerant, but I hate football and the idiotic phenomenon it produces. I hate it even more because people food the streets, meaning it took me forever to get home. And all this to see an ape; a Brazilian [Ronaldinho], but an ape just the same.” After being heavily criticized, Trevino apologized to the club and to Ronaldinho about his racist and inconvenient comment. Not surprisingly, he received no punishment, underlining how Mexican football officials have yet not properly dealt with the huge problem of racism.




Decio de Maria, president of Liga MX (Mexico’s top league), openly argued that racism is not a problem, not in Mexico nor on soccer fields. According to president de Maria, “[Mexico] is a country where we use nicknames. On the streets, they single people out. There are profanities that, when they are said, do not mean that they literally mean. Calling someone by a nickname is not discrimination. Those who cross the line should be taken to court.” However, to what extent is “calling someone by a nickname not discrimination”? And does racism only involve physical aggression? With his statement, de Maria is missing many important ideas of what racism and discrimination really are and how they are affecting individuals in our society.
However, despite de Maria’s involvement, Valeria Berumen, important official of a Mexican government office, testified against racism involving soccer and racism in general. According to Berumen, “there are two engines that push discrimination. One is football. The other is the Internet. They have the ability to spread positive messages, but they also can spread discrimination, racism and xenophobia.”



Early this year, the Mexican league decided to adopt the FIFA’s rules involving racism and discrimination. In fact, according to FIFA, referees have the right to stop a game if racist issues take place. If these incident(s) continue, the referees can take the team off the field for 10 minutes. If persisting, they have the right to completely stop or suspend the match. However, so far, Mexican referees have not acted under any of the rules implemented, suggesting the need for further radical changes.
Unfortunately, Ronaldinho’s case is one of the many cases involving racism. For instance, in February 2014, fans of Pumas in Mexico City chanted monkey noises towards a Colombian player. The year before, an Ecuadoran player was the target of monkey noises too.




This article is very significant because it demonstrates that racism is present not only in the United States, between whites and blacks, but also outside of the United States, between individuals who have the same skin color. Moreover, it demonstrates that racism is not only present in our economy, health system or education system but also in sports. Unfortunately, all around the world, players from team sports and from different racial and ethnic backgrounds are constantly victims of verbal or physical aggression involving racism and little is done to diminish this.


5 comments:

  1. This is so true and such a major problem in soccer. I liked seeing it from this perspective. It's something that should be addressed much more than it is.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Even our men's soccer team experienced some social tension while playing soccer in Italy early this semester. The European teams have majority white players and we have diversified throughout the years so it was interesting for them to actually experience and come back and describe the strange vibes and, for the few who could understand the Italian chirping, the harsh remarks they may have thrown at them. I am pleased with the addition of the discrimination rules into the FIFA rule book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What I find ironic is that it is said “calling someone by a nickname not discrimination” yet Redskiin is a nickname for Native Americans and people think it needs to be changed. There is no standard for this kind of thing which makes it hard for ANYONE to make a decision whether something is offensive or not. Everything depends on people's feelings and it is ridiculous that people can say nicknames are okay and not discriminatory but when it comes to the Redskins, everyone thinks that the name should be changed because that nickname is discriminatory. Who decides what is discriminatory and what isn't, and why should we believe them?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was really interesting to read. I had known about racism in soccer in the BPL but I had never heard of such a thing in the Mexican leagues. It is interesting that even someone of such superstar status could be verbally abused in the sport of soccer where talent is respected so highly. It is nice to see that our soccer teams here at Wheaton are well diversified with talent coming from all different backgrounds.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Last year in anthropology class, I had to read and talk about articles based off of racism in soccer, and this blog entry was interesting to read after having a bit of an understanding already. A lot of what I'd read about was based in Africa, but the Mexican side to it is really different. The regulations put into place are baffling and it's horrifying to read about them. A depressing, but very important subject to talk about, and something that needs to be regulated as well, but in good ways. Great job!

    ReplyDelete